Michael Clayton
Director: Tony Gilroy
Cast: George Clooney, Tom Wilkinson, Tilda Swinton, Sydney Pollack
Genre: Drama
Rated: R
Review By:
Michael Dance
School:
NYU Tisch '07
Quote:
"...And hey, I met you. You are not cool." -Almost Famous
Michael Clayton
Review By: Michael Dance
MichaelDance@TheCinemaSource.com
We’ve got two reviews for you for this one. On top is Michael Dance’s, followed by another take by TheCinemaSource.com alum Stephen Snart. Enjoy…
Michael Clayton
I love that my job is to write about movies, but since movies can be about anything, that gets me into trouble sometimes. Take
Michael Clayton. Here’s a movie that takes place in the world of giant law firms and bigger corporations, a world I know nothing
about, and most of the conversations are so dense and complex I felt like I needed to pass the bar to understand it all. That the movie
so willingly delves into its subject matter without pandering to a mass audience is quite commendable; it also means I’m going to have
a hard time explaining the intricacies of the plot, even with the press notes at my side.
The basic hook is this: Michael Clayton (George Clooney) is a “fixer” at Kenner, Bach & Ledeen, an NYC law firm: whenever
they need to clean up messes (a rich current client is involved in a hit and run, for example), he makes the calls and does the damage
control. The firm is currently well on its way to reaching a multi-million-dollar settlement of a class action lawsuit with a company
called U/North, represented by litigator Karen Crowder (Tilda Swinton). Before that happens, the main Kenner Bach attorney
on the case, Arthur Edens (Tom Wilkinson), goes nuts, has a crisis of conscience, strips off his clothes during a conference
and runs through a parking lot naked. Clayton is brought in to fix things.
Michael Clayton is a thriller, yes; we know that because the movie opens with his car exploding (without him in it), and then
jumps back to “Four Days Earlier” so we can see how things reached that point. But the key to the movie’s success is that it’s
legitimately interested, not in explosions or murders, but with the lives and jobs of its characters. Clayton himself, of course, has a
personal life in shambles: he’s burnt out but has lost his savings, he has a young son from a failed marriage, and he has a strained
relationship with his cop brother. But the film also pays close attention to its other characters, like Edens, who’s not just a simple
nutcase but is actually a wildly smart lawyer who’s been battling manic depression, and Marty Bach (Sydney Pollack), one of
the partners at the firm, who goes way back with Clayton.
The fine actors who inhabit these roles are responsible for breathing life into them; George Clooney gives a deft, modulated
performance, while Wilkinson and Swinton manage to both be slimy and sympathetic, although one is more sympathetic and one is
more slimy. The real star of the show here, however, is writer/director Tony Gilroy.
and the hostage-negotiation drama Proof of Life, he seems fascinated by men who are very good at jobs that are done out of
desperation rather than enjoyment. This is his first movie as a director, and he wholeheartedly succeeds in that department by letting
his screenplay and the actors do most of the work. He stages his conversations simply, letting the dialogue notch up the tension
rather than the camera work, and often lingers on his cast’s faces for a few beats at the end of each scene.
Gilroy is also going for some complex symbolism, in one scene involving a few horses when Clayton finds himself out of the city in a
rural area, and another with a subplot involving a book that Clayton’s son is reading. These passages don’t altogether succeed; the
horses are unnecessary and turn out to simply be a random plot convenience, while his son’s book is meant to illuminate one
character’s state of mind but ends up being rather unnecessary. Actually, since the kid disappears from the movie completely two-
thirds of the way through, and Clayton already has a divorce, a sick father, an estranged brother, and oh yeah, a gambling problem to
worry about, the kid was probably unnecessary.
Minor points aside, it’s a well-done movie. I didn’t understand everything that was happening all the time thanks to my complete
ignorance of the law world, but Gilroy makes it easy for us to at least understand the motivations at work, and even better, he made me
care about what happened. At the end of the movie, when everything has come to a resolution, the camera once again lingers on
Michael Clayton’s face in a continuous shot as the end credits begin to roll. He’s not a desperate man anymore, but there’s no visible
relief, no smile. He just sits there, thinking about what he’s going to do now.
Movie Grade: B+
Michael Clayton































