TCS Entertainment Network > TheCinemaSource · TheBluraySource · TheTheatreSource
The_Perfect_Holiday-1-Queen_LatifahThe_Perfect_Holiday-2-Gabrielle_Union-Morris_ChestnutThe_Perfect_Holiday-3-Queen_Latifah-Terrence_HowardThe_Perfect_Holiday-4-Katt_Williams-Charlie_MurphyThe_Perfect_Holiday-5-Rachel_True-Jill_Marie_Jones-Gabrielle_UnionThe_Perfect_Holiday-6-Lance_Rivera-Queen_Latifah

The Perfect Holiday

Director: Lance Rivera

Cast: Morris Chestnut, Gabrielle Union, Terrence Howard, Queen Latifah, Katt WIlliams, Charlie Murphy, Faizon Love

Genre: Comedy / Drama / Holiday

Rated: PG

Review By:
Rocco Passafuime

School:
SUNY Purchase '05

Quote:
"I don't compromise my values and I don't compromise my work. I won't give in." -Michael Moore

The_Perfect_Holiday-Poster
Release Date: December 12th, 2007
Overall Grade: C+

The Perfect Holiday

Review By: Rocco Passafuime
RoccoPassafuime@TheCinemaSource.com

The Perfect Holiday

It's Christmastime once again and with that has come the fairly predictable glut of heartwarming, family-friendly seasonal movies, particularly in the genre of comedy. While Christmas-themed films, often a usually hit or miss affair, have been around since Hollywood's golden age, very few have been made that specifically targets the African American community.

However, with the rise of playwright-turned-filmmaker Tyler Perry, whose independent films have become unexpected box office successes particularly on the strength of African American audiences, it's signaled an increased output of more suburban and domestic African American-centered fare. Now this increased wave has ventured into the Christmas season with the romantic comedy The Perfect Holiday

Nancy (Gabrielle Union) is a divorcee who has been so wrapped up in taking care of her three children that she has seemingly put aside finding love. Benjamin (Morris Chestnut) is a struggling songwriter who takes a job as a mall Santa, with his friend Jamal (Faizon Love) as his elf.

One day, while encountering Nancy's daughter Emily (Khail Bryant) during his rounds as Santa, she expresses to him that what she really wants for Christmas is for her mother to be happy. With that information tipped off to him, Benjamin soon bumps into Nancy and asks her out on a date.

However, despite Benjamin's refreshing earnestness and sincerity, he stumbles upon a few outside roadblocks in any chance of happiness with her. He discovers that selfish and self-indulgent gangsta rapper J. Jizzy (Charlie Murphy), who has hired Benjamin to write a song for his upcoming Christmas album, is Nancy's ex-husband.

On top of that, her oldest son John-John (Malik Hammond), who blindly idolizes and misses his father's presence in his life, despises Benjamin's presence and schemes to try and cut him out of the picture. Now, Benjamin has to not only win Nancy's affection, but that of John-John.

While the film certainly has good intent in creating a Christmas movie centered on African American families, The Perfect Holiday feels a bit hamstrung by trying be too many different things for its audience. On one hand, it tries to harken back Christmas romantic comedies of Hollywood's golden age, with its goofy 1960's-inspired animated opening credits and the insertion of Queen Latifah and Terrence Howard as respectively the film's narrator and antagonist.

On the other hand, it detours often into being a satire of the materialism of gangsta hip-hop culture, as evidenced by the scenes with Charlie Murphy's clearly Diddy and 50 Cent-inspired J. Jizzy. The film has a fantastic cast, with a few funny scenes from Faizon Love and particularly Murphy, who is hilarious in every scene.

Its well-intentioned core story is upbeat and family-friendly without any of the movie's cheeriness feeling forced. However, the insertion of narrators, even with excellent talents like Latifah and Howard, into different parts of the main story not only adds to the film's already uneven

structure, but undoes the more nuanced core story with the now all-too familiar holiday film elements of cloying good cheer cheesiness.

All in all, The Perfect Holiday is a potentially good film that's ultimately lessened by its own ambition to be upbeat and family friendly. This is caused by its uneven and cloying wrapping up of 1960's-style Christmas movie, domestic African American romantic comedy, and cultural satire. Luckily, much of the principal cast is great and the more unnecessary additional elements don't deflect film's good-natured core story too much, making it among the better of the holiday film output of recent years.

Movie Grade: C+

Synopsis:

A young girl turns to a department store Santa (Chestnut) in the hopes that he will help find a new husband for her divorced mother (Union).

Leave a Reply

*